Cerqular Review: Is the "Eco Amazon" Truly Reliable?

Technical and Functional Analysis: How Does It Work?

To understand if Cerqular is right for you, you need to understand its business model. It is not a classic store that stocks everything in a giant warehouse.

The "Marketplace" Model

Cerqular operates as a trusted intermediary. The platform connects conscious buyers (you) with ethical sellers.

• Concretely: When you place an order on Cerqular, the order is transmitted directly to the brand (the seller). It is the brand that packs and ships your product.
• The advantage: This allows Cerqular to offer a gigantic catalog without managing inventory, thus reducing waste.
• Cerqular's role: They act as the "gatekeeper." They manage the payment, first-level customer service, and, most importantly, the vetting of sellers.

The "Vetting" System (Verification)

This is the heart of the engine. Unlike Amazon, where anyone can sell anything, Cerqular imposes a strict filter. To be accepted, a brand must prove its commitments according to several criteria:

• Materials: Organic, recycled, upcycled.
• Ethics: Fair trade, vegan, cruelty-free.
• Business Model: Circularity, carbon neutrality.

If you see a product on the site, a human has validated that the brand isn't cutting corners. For the user, it's a huge mental time-saver.

User Experience (UX)

The interface is clean, modern, and resembles current e-commerce standards. What sets Cerqular apart is its filtering system by values. You don't just search for "Red T-shirt"; you can search for "Red T-shirt + Vegan + Organic Cotton + Made Locally."
For users in the US, the platform often highlights brands available domestically or with optimized shipping to North America, which is a real plus to avoid the carbon footprint of a package coming from Asia or Europe.

---

The Strong Points: Why Use Cerqular?

After exploring the platform, here are the aspects that really stand out.

1. The End of the "Greenwashing" Mental Load

This is the number one argument. When you buy on generalist sites, you have to read the fine print, check the composition, and look for where it's manufactured. On Cerqular, the pre-selection work is done.
Concrete example: If you are looking for a moisturizer, you have the guarantee that it hasn't been tested on animals and that the ingredients are clean. You don't need to have a scanning app like Yuka open in parallel.

2. A Complete "Lifestyle" Catalog

Often, eco-friendly shops are very specialized (just fashion, or just zero waste). Cerqular covers everything:

• Fashion: Men, Women, Kids (with brands like Beyond Retro for vintage or ethical designers).
• Home: Decor, zero waste kitchen, linens.
• Beauty: Solid cosmetics, organic skincare.
• Grocery: Dry foods, teas, superfoods (strong on the global market with local partners).

You can literally redo your wardrobe and your kitchen in the same place.

3. Support for the Circular and Local Economy

Cerqular isn't content with just selling "new eco-friendly" items. They push hard on vintage, second-hand, and upcycling. It's consistent with their name (Circular).
Furthermore, for specific markets, they integrate local sellers (like Slowood or SpiceBox Organics in Asia, or local equivalents in the US). This allows you to support entrepreneurs in your region rather than always importing from overseas.

4. Price Transparency

Although the products are often premium (quality requires it), the platform is transparent. There are no hidden fees when adding to the cart, except for delivery, which is calculated based on the seller.

---

The Limits and Downsides

Let's be frank and objective. Despite its beautiful promises, Cerqular has structural flaws that you need to know about to avoid disappointment.

1. The Complexity of Shipping Costs ("Multi-Shipping")

This is the major flaw of all dropshipping marketplaces, and Cerqular is no exception.

• The problem: If you buy jeans from Brand A and soap from Brand B, you will pay shipping fees twice. Why? Because the jeans leave from Warehouse A and the soap from Warehouse B.
• The consequence: Your cart total can climb quickly if you aren't careful to group your purchases by brand.
• Tip: Try to maximize your cart with a single seller at a time to amortize the costs, or look for sellers who offer free shipping over a certain amount.

2. Uneven Return Policies

Cerqular imposes standards, but each seller retains some autonomy over their return policy.

• Some sellers offer free returns.
• Others require return shipping costs to be at your expense (and if the seller is overseas, that can get expensive).
• The impact: You must check the policy of each item in your cart before paying. It's not as simple as an "Amazon return" where you put everything in the same box.

3. Variable Delivery Times

If you order on the US version but choose a product shipped from London or Hong Kong, don't expect delivery in 48 hours.

• Delays can vary from 3 days (local seller) to 3 weeks (international).
• The carbon impact of international transport can also contradict your ecological approach if you don't filter by location.

4. A "Premium" Price Positioning

Sustainability has a cost: paying workers fairly and using organic materials costs more than fast fashion.

• Cerqular is not a discount platform. The entry ticket is high.
• Example: A basic organic cotton t-shirt will often cost between $30 and $50, compared to $10 at a classic retailer. This isn't a flaw in itself, but it is a barrier for small budgets.

---

Comparison with Alternatives

To help you place Cerqular, here is how it compares to the competition:

1. Slowood (The Hong Kong Alternative)

If you are looking at the Asian market, Slowood is a serious direct competitor (and ironically, sometimes a partner).

• Slowood Advantage: Physical stores in HK, unified local logistics (one single package), very sharp selection on zero waste and food.
• Cerqular Advantage: A much vaster catalog on fashion and international vintage.

2. EarthHero (The American Giant)

This is the "Cerqular" of the USA.

• Comparison: EarthHero has a slightly more centralized model for logistics in the US, which simplifies shipments.
• Verdict: Since you are in the US, EarthHero is often simpler for domestic goods. However, if you are looking for a more global approach or specific international marketplace finds, Cerqular offers more flexibility.

3. Etsy (The Generalist)

• Comparison: Etsy has everything, from the very good to the very bad.
• The problem with Etsy: The "sustainable" filter is often abused by sellers doing dropshipping from China (AliExpress in disguise).
• Verdict: Cerqular wins hands down on trust and verification. On Etsy, it's up to you to investigate the seller.

---

In-Depth Analysis: Zoom on 3 Key Categories

To give more substance to this review, let's look at the value of the offer in the main aisles.

Fashion and Accessories

This is undoubtedly Cerqular's strongest category. You can find everything:

• Basics: T-shirts, organic cotton underwear.
• Sport: Leggings made from recycled plastic, technical sports bras.
• Vintage: A luxury second-hand selection (bags, jackets) that is often very well curated.
  My opinion: The selection is excellent, but watch out for sizes. Since brands come from all over the world, a US "M" is not a Japanese or European "M". Always consult the size guide specific to the product page.

Home and Zero Waste

Here, Cerqular excels in everyday objects that replace disposables.

• Water bottles, lunch boxes, beeswax wraps.
• Artisanal decoration (baskets, textiles).
  My opinion: This is the "easiest" category to start with. Prices are more accessible than fashion, and the risks of "wrong size" are nonexistent. It's ideal for a first test purchase.

Beauty and Wellness

The beauty section is strict: no toxic products.

• Solid shampoos, vegetable oils, natural makeup.
  My opinion: Very reassuring for those with sensitive skin or who refuse animal testing. However, for liquids, check the origin carefully to avoid having a bottle of micellar water travel 6,000 miles.

---

Prices and Savings Tip

As mentioned, prices are in the medium-high range of the ethical market. This is the price of quality and fair remuneration for artisans.

However, there are ways to optimize your budget:

1. Group purchases: Buy several items from the same seller to pay shipping costs only once.
2. Promo Code: If you decide to place an order, know that there is currently an active code.
   • The tip: Use the code PLDEALS at checkout. This allows you to get a 10% discount on your order. It's not huge, but on a cart of $100 or $200, it often covers the shipping costs, which is always good to take.

---